Research insights
Direct Marketing: Measuring Response and Incremental Value
Direct marketing addresses a defined person or organisation with an offer and a way to respond. Email, telephone calls, SMS, addressed mail and event follow-up can all serve this purpose. Its effectiveness depends on whether the contact creates a useful response at an acceptable cost and respects the recipient’s preferences.

On this page
A campaign report should distinguish contact delivery, response, completed action and incremental business value. Counting every purchase after a message as a campaign success can include customers who would have bought anyway. A clear measurement plan makes that uncertainty visible.

Define the action before choosing the channel
Start with a specific decision and response: confirming an appointment, requesting a demonstration, returning to a store or placing an order. Identify the relevant customer group and the reason the offer might matter now. A recent enquiry and an old database entry should not automatically receive the same message.
Choose the channel around the information needed. A physical sample invitation may suit addressed mail; a complex enquiry may require a conversation; a brief reminder may need only a short message. These are options to test, not a ranking of channels that works for every audience.
Keep the stages and denominators separate
Report how many contacts were attempted, successfully delivered or reached, and eligible for analysis. Then define a response and a conversion. A person asking a question is a response; a confirmed, qualifying order may be the conversion. A complaint is also a response, but it should not inflate the positive-response total.
For each rate, state the denominator. Response per delivered message and response per attempted contact answer different questions. Define a common observation window and remove duplicate responses when a person receives several contacts. For event follow-up, distinguish a collected business card from an actual conversation about the offer.
Test the offer without changing everything at once
A useful experiment varies one planned element, such as the proposed benefit, contact timing or message structure. Keep eligibility and fulfilment comparable. Decide the primary outcome in advance, and avoid repeatedly stopping a test when a favourable result first appears.
Consider a hypothetical maintenance business inviting previous customers to request a service quotation. One message explains the booking process; another stresses a defined package. The comparison should assess qualified quotation requests and completed work, while recording opt-outs and complaints. More replies alone would not settle which message is better.
Estimate the value added by the contact
Where feasible, retain a comparable group that does not receive the campaign. Random allocation can help make the groups comparable, provided the design avoids contamination and has enough observations for the decision. Compare outcomes over the same period rather than comparing a busy holiday with a quiet month.
Define incremental contribution as contribution from additional business attributed to the campaign before campaign costs. Then a working campaign return calculation is incremental contribution minus campaign cost, divided by campaign cost. State which costs and assumptions are included. This differs from dividing attributed revenue by advertising spend.
Include creative production, staff time, data preparation, delivery, incentives and relevant fulfilment costs. If a campaign mainly seeks future enquiries, report the uncertainty around their eventual value instead of treating all leads as completed revenue.
Study the experience of being contacted
Ask recipients whether they recognised the sender, understood why they were contacted and could find the next step. Review frequency across channels, not just within each channel. A customer receiving an email, message and call may experience one sequence of contact even when separate teams manage it.
Maintain clear contact preferences and a practical way to decline further marketing. Investigate complaints and unanswered questions alongside positive outcomes. These findings can improve list relevance, message clarity and handover to service teams.
For audience and response research, explore market research services or discuss a campaign evaluation brief with the intended action, comparison design, cost definition and customer-experience questions.
Related reading
Latest posts
- Market Research: Building a Market Research Report for Investment Funds
Survey Sample Size: How Many Respondents Are Enough?
Survey Data Collection Methods in Vietnam: How to Choose- Technology Adoption in Enterprises: How to Research Employee Behavior
How to Write a Market Research Brief for an Accurate Quote


