Research insights
Online Reviews: Researching Their Role in Brand Choice
Online reviews give prospective customers accounts of other people’s experiences. To understand their role in brand choice, examine what shoppers actually read, how they judge relevance and which questions the reviews help answer. A star average alone does not explain the decision.

On this page
Research should distinguish the effect of review information from product suitability, price, availability and previous brand experience. It should also recognise that people who write reviews are not automatically representative of everyone who purchased or considered the offer.

Look beyond the average rating
Record the review count, dates, relevant product variant and substantive content. A comment about an earlier version or a different service location may not answer the current shopper’s question. A detailed explanation of use can be more relevant to a particular task than an unexplained score.
Ask shoppers to describe the review they remember and why it mattered. Did it clarify fit, delivery, durability or the handling of a problem? Do not assume that a positive review influences everyone positively or that a negative one automatically ends consideration.
Observe reviews within the purchase journey
Use a realistic comparison task with intended customers. Ask them to inspect the available information and explain their shortlist. Observe whether they consult reviews before checking specifications, after narrowing options or only when uncertain about a particular claim.
For a hypothetical small-appliance purchase, one shopper might seek evidence about cleaning while another checks delivery and returns. Keep the product and total price visible. Removing those details creates an artificial task in which reviews may appear more decisive than they are in a real choice.
Separate helpful detail from perceived authenticity
Ask which features make a review seem credible and what remains uncertain. A purchase label, photograph or detailed story can be a cue that readers notice; research should not treat the cue as conclusive proof that every claim is genuine.
When analysing a review collection, document inclusion criteria, duplicates and the period covered. Code specific experiences and reasons rather than only positive or negative sentiment. Keep mixed feedback: a customer may like the product but dislike delivery, and those findings belong to different teams.
Evaluate the business response
Show an appropriately anonymised negative review with alternative response approaches. Ask whether readers understand the proposed next step and whether the response addresses the actual issue. A polite reply that avoids the question may not help someone deciding whether to buy.
Public responses should avoid exposing customer information. Provide a route to investigate individual cases privately and connect recurring issues to operational review. A low rating is not, by itself, proof of a service failure or evidence that a review is fake; investigate the underlying account.
Collect feedback without selecting only praise
Invite eligible customers to describe their actual experience using a neutral request. Keep a research interview separate from a public review request. Participation in a study should not be presented as a promise to endorse the business.
The US FTC’s January 2022 guide to soliciting reviews advises against asking only customers expected to leave favourable feedback and against making incentives depend on positivity. This is a US transparency reference; teams should also check the applicable market and platform requirements.
Use review evidence with its limits visible
Review themes can guide interviews, product information and service improvements. They cannot on their own establish the prevalence of a problem across all customers or prove that a response caused additional sales. If estimating an effect, define the comparison and account for other information in the journey.
Report where the reviews came from, which customers the study covers and what was tested. Explore market research services or discuss a brand-choice research brief focused on the questions customers use reviews to resolve.
Related reading
Latest posts
- Effective M&A (Mergers & Acquisitions) Opportunity Research
- Market Research: Building a Market Research Report for Investment Funds
Survey Sample Size: How Many Respondents Are Enough?
Survey Data Collection Methods in Vietnam: How to Choose- Technology Adoption in Enterprises: How to Research Employee Behavior


